How a first quote is usually produced
From the factory side, the first reply to an inquiry is a sales document. In many factories it is written by the sales team from a price list and recent orders, before an engineer has read your drawing. Its job is to keep the conversation going. So it tends to assume the factory’s default material grade, its standard finish, plain export packing and its most comfortable quantity. Then it quotes FOB from whichever port the sales team usually uses.
None of this is dishonest. But a quote written that way and one written by an engineer against your drawing are not prices for the same product.
What is inside the price
| Line | What drives it | What to ask for in writing |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Grade, weight or thickness, and the market price of steel, aluminium, copper, rubber or resin on the quote date | Material standard and grade (e.g. a named EN, ASTM or GB grade), net weight per piece, and whether the price is tied to a material index |
| Processing | Number of operations, machine time, scrap rate, labour | Process route: which operations are done in-house and which are subcontracted |
| Surface treatment | Plating, painting, coating type and thickness, salt-spray hours | Treatment spec and the test that proves it |
| Tooling / moulds | Pattern, die or mould cost: one-off, sometimes partly refunded after a set volume | Tooling cost as a separate line, who owns the tool, how long it is kept, and whether any refund applies |
| Samples | Setup cost of a small run, often charged and sometimes credited against the first order | Sample price, lead time, and whether it is credited |
| Packing and marking | Export carton vs retail box, inner packs, labels, pallets, your logo | A packing spec, with carton marks and pallet type |
| Testing and documents | Material certificates, test reports, certificates of origin | Which documents ship with each batch and who pays for them |
| Delivery term | EXW, FOB or CIF, and which port. Inland trucking to the port is real cost | Incoterm plus named port, e.g. "FOB Qingdao" |
| Payment and validity | Deposit share, currency, exchange rate, raw-material price risk | Payment terms and how many days the price is valid |
The five assumptions that make quotes incomparable
- Material grade. "Steel" or "rubber" is not a specification. The grade is usually the largest single difference between two quotes for the same drawing. When a supplier writes "equivalent", ask for the grade it actually means, and for the mill or test certificate that will prove it.
- Tolerance and finish. A drawing tolerance the factory cannot hold is often quoted anyway and argued about after the samples. Ask each supplier to confirm the critical dimensions it can hold, with its measuring method.
- Packing. Retail packaging, inner cartons and labelling can change the unit price noticeably on low-value items. Quotes on plain export cartons look cheaper and are not wrong; they are just a different product.
- Quantity tier. A unit price only means something next to its quantity. Ask every supplier for the same tiers (for example your trial order, your expected annual volume, and one step in between), and ask what drives the MOQ.
- Incoterm and port. EXW from an inland city and FOB from a port are different prices for the same goods. Pin both the term and the named port.
MOQ: real minimums and negotiating positions
A minimum order quantity is real when it comes from the process. Examples:
- a casting pattern that only pays off over a run
- a fabric dye lot
- a mould changeover
- a minimum material purchase from the mill
It is a negotiating position when it comes from the sales team’s preference. The way to tell is to ask why the MOQ is what it is. A factory with a process reason will tell you the reason, and often what a smaller run would cost instead. A higher unit price, a tooling charge or a stock material are common alternatives.
Tooling: put ownership in writing
For castings, forgings, stampings and moulded parts, the tool is often the largest single cost of a first order. Agree in writing:
- that the tool is yours once paid
- that it is marked as yours
- how long the factory will store it
- that it will not be used for anyone else’s parts
- on what terms you can move it to another factory
A quote that hides tooling inside the unit price makes the tool hard to claim later.
A comparison layout that works
When we compare suppliers, we put every quote into the same rows. You can use the same structure yourself:
| Field | Supplier A | Supplier B | Supplier C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legal entity quoting (Chinese name) | |||
| Factory or trading company (evidence) | |||
| Material grade quoted | |||
| Unit price at tier 1 / 2 / 3 | |||
| Tooling cost, ownership | |||
| Sample cost, lead time, credited? | |||
| Production lead time after sample approval | |||
| Packing as quoted | |||
| Incoterm and port | |||
| Payment terms, price validity | |||
| Documents and certificates included |
Our sample report shows this layout filled in with invented example data. Our sourcing report (from $399 per product) does the follow-up questions until every row describes the same product.
Warning signs in a quote
- A price well below the others with an identical specification claim and no explanation. Ask which assumption differs before you assume a better factory.
- A supplier that won’t itemise tooling, samples or packing.
- An Incoterm or port that changes between the first quote and the proforma invoice.
- Very short price validity on a product without volatile raw materials, or none stated on one with them.
- A proforma invoice issued by a different company from the one that quoted. See how to verify a supplier.
Questions we get about this
Should I always take the cheapest quote once the specs match?
Not automatically. Once the quotes describe the same product, the remaining differences are capacity, how the supplier handles problems, and who actually does each process. That is what a visit or a live video of the line tells you.
Can you negotiate prices for me?
We ask the questions that make quotes comparable and point out where a price looks out of line, and we will ask suppliers to requote on a clarified spec. You contract and pay the factory directly, and we take nothing from it, so there is no incentive for us to push a higher price.